This isn’t a list built from Yelp stars or convenience—it’s a hands-on, slice-by-slice exploration of Vermont. I’m tracking down the state’s true pizza greats across our 10 cities and 237 towns—the ones worth driving for, talking about, and remembering. It’s part food hunt, part road trip, and part appreciation of Vermont’s small towns, winding roads, and mountain views. Every stop, every bite, is another step toward finding the best pizza in the Green Mountain State.
The Tillerman - Bristol
Current Rank
#1
La di da Pizza - Burlington
Current Rank #2 Tied
Folino's - Shelburne
Current Rank #2 Tied
Pizza on Main - Morristown
Current Rank #4
Penzo Pizza Company - Montpeiler*
Current Rank #5
19 South Main - Wilmington
Current Rank #6
The Parker Pie Company - Glover
Current Rank
#7
Goodman's American Pie
Current Rank #8
iPie Pizzaria- Killington
Current Rank #9
Pizza Stone - Chester
Current Rank #10
Valley Craft Ales - Wilmington
Current Rank #11
Lake Bamoseen Lodge - Bamonseen
Current Rank
#12
Picasso - Stowe
Current Rank #13
Mr. Mikes Pizza - Burlington
Current Rank #14
Pizza Soul - Waitsfield
Current Rank #15
Christo's - Manchester
Current Rank
#16
Positive Pie - Montpelier
Current Rank #17
Beer Naked Brewery - Marlboro
Current Rank #18
Rockers Pizzaria - Vergennes
Current Rank #19
Pie in the Sky - St. Albans
Current Rank #20
Vermont Pie & Pasta - Derby
Current and Future Rank #Last
Kingdom Crust Company - St. Johnsbury
Woodbelly Pizza - Montpelier
Pearl Street Pizza - Barre
Off the Rails - Ludlow
Sam's Wood Fired Pizza - Manchester
Mach's Market - Pawlet
Cornerstone Pizza - Barre
Leonardo’s Pizza - South Burlington
Three Needs - Burlington
Jimmz Pizza - Waterbury
Stone's Throw Pizza - Waterbury
Piesanos - Burlington
Pizza 44 - Burlington
Pizzeria Verità - Burlington
Cara Mia's - Rutland
Mimmo's - Essex
Morningside Bakery - Brandon
Green Peppers - Middlebury
TBD
TBD
TBD
TBD
TBD
TBD
TBD
TBD
TBD
I don't know how the e-mail function works. I'm working on it.